Why this song is heavy to hear. Keep fighting astro. 😢❤❤

We will always be with you and OT6. Thank you Sanha for this. Binnie is smiling so brightly from above.

im crying - the emotions, the message he sent to binnie, the lyrics he changed from twenty five twenty one to twenty six twenty four T.T Bin ah we miss you

twenty six, twenty four🥹 a thoughtful birthday gift for moonbin🥺🥺

Sanha, your voice is so beautiful and comforting. I'm sure Moonbin will love this gift alot! Happy birthday, Moonbin~ 🫶

Watching this after your live💜 My heart is healing..happy birthday our Moon. Keep shining. Be happy. Be healthy.

AROHA 💜✡️🍀🐱🩷🌙✨😔😭Todos los dias escucho esta linda y profunda canción de mensajes muy nostagicos . extraño a mi MOONBIN x siemrpe 💜

산하야 괜찮아 다 괜찮아 괜찮아질거야

Thank you Ddana 💜 Bin is surely smiling now ☺️ I will go outside to see our beautiful and bright moon in the night sky.

The empty chair actually had me sobbing. Love you Moon Bin, and Sanha. 💜🌕

@araceliherrera1172

4 ай бұрын

A mí también me hace llorar ya la he escuchado tantas veces que perdí la cuenta

@tinacoriag2589

4 ай бұрын

Me too😥

@jennylee5575

4 ай бұрын

Heartbroken 💔 😭

@liaAroha

2 ай бұрын

​@@araceliherrera1172me pasa lo mismo, la oigo a diario❤

@virginialopez6805

Ай бұрын

Ayyyy 😭😭😭

멋지게 성장한 산하야 빈이가 너무 자랑스러워할거야 언제 들어도 너의 따스한 마음이 느껴진다

SANHA 💜💜💜

Lovely, thank you for this. We all miss Moonbin so much. 🌑😥🩵

@Chaeunwoo-dn5qh

4 ай бұрын

내 게시물에 좋아요와 댓글을 남겨주셔서 감사합니다. 사랑해요 차은우 🥰❤️

How he has grown. Moon Bin must be very proud of Sanha now. The little flower has bloom. Very proud. Great song and thank you for dedicating this to Moon Bin

This is so beautiful!! 😭

Maravillosa canción y su voz perfecta

I know moonbin is very proud of you sanha stay strong he always be in our hearts 💜💜

Thank you for such a beautiful cover Sanha! I'm sure he was sitting right next to you and listening. Happy birthday to our dearest Moonbin!

CUZ EVERY NIGHT IM TALKING TO THE MOON

sanha I love your voice so much it's amazing

A beautiful song & tribute, Sanha. Thank you for honoring your friend & brother on his birthday. I know your heart still hurts. We all miss Moonbin. Just know that Aroha are always here & you are never alone. Know you and all Astro members are loved. Cheer up sweet maknae & be well. Much ❤

happy birthday, moonbin! 💜🤍 thank you sanha 🥺💜

Cheer up, Sahna Bin will be proud of every goal you achieve in your life, Aroha is with all of you and Bin too.💜💜💜💜💜💜

0:58 “스물 여섯 스물 넷” 하면서 빈 의자 바라보는 산하 보니까 왜 이렇게 눈물이 나는지.. 다들 너무 많이 힘들지 않았으면..

I am exaited for this video😍 I miss you moobin😭😭but happy birthday our moon🎉🎉

Uri maknae you prepared so beautiful gift for your Bin hyung... Just know that he surely is proud of you.... Hugs for you Sanha ya❤

I can only imagine how much sorrow we are growing through as their fans, but how much sorrow are they enduring when they are personally affected by the loss of someone they knew personally, someone they lived, ate, slept with, someone they worked with, someone they dreamed with?

sanha, I'm very sorry for you, our little star Moonbin will always be with you. I dreamed so much of coming to the concert to see Bin, but I didn't have time... 😭

My sanha🥺 happy birthday again our moon🤍🌙

I miss you moonbin, I'm watching this 10× and still crying

As a 8 years old Aroha, i love Sanha’s voice since he debuted but i never though that his voice now can affect my feelings this much😔 sanha i really want you to be happy…

Moon Bin would be very proud of you!! Lots of Love Sanha.

Finally sanha cover comeback 🥹 . Thank you ddana this is so beautiful, we will always love you , binnie , and the members ^^❤

It's a full moon here today. You'll always shine, our star Binnie 💜🌌 Happy Birthday

I want to hug you tight, sanha i love you

I have never heard such a beautiful song in my life, it hurts to see it. An angel's message to another angel. It hurts so much to watch, but I wanted to feel it all the time.😭😭😭 Moonbin&Sanha 4ever!💜💜💜I love you to the moon and back🌙

i have chills 🥺🥺 his voice is so gorgeous.. what a beautiful cover him changing the 25, 21 lyrics to 26, 24 broke me

Now i know the lyrics, it's for moobin 😢❤ Thanks for always remember him. (I can't hold my tear, ohhh god)

빈이오빠도 이 영상 꼭 봤으면 좋았을텐데... 산하오빠의 마음이 너무 잘 느껴졌고 눈물 흘리지않고 강한마음으로 잘 지내다보니 벌써 빈이오빠 생일이었고 빈이오빠를 축하해주기위해 산하오빠가 노래를 불러주는데 왜 갑자기 2023년으로 다시 돌아간것만 같은 느낌일까요... 작년에 저는 학교가기 몇시간전에 알아서 학교에서 하루종일 울고 집에와서 하루종일 울고 그랬어요... 이 노래를 들으니까 갑자기 그때가 생각이 나네요... 허허... 산하오빠도 많이 힘들었잖아요 지금도 힘들어하는 것 같아서 마음이 그렇게 좋지는 않아요 그래도 우리 아스트로와 아로하 힘들어도 꼭 다 이겨내고 슬픔도 어서 이겨냈으면 좋겠습니다... 우리 모두 행복합시다 하늘에 있는 빈이오빠가 더 밝게 웃을 수 있게...

@user-es7jp1nv5i

4 ай бұрын

맞아요 그랬음 좋겠어요 빈이오빠가 거기서는 아프지 않으셨음 좋겠어요 건강했음 좋겠고 울컥해요 오빠가 너무 보고싶네요 제 최애였는데ㅠㅠ 얼마나 힘이 들었으면 먼저 갔을까 하는 생각이ㅠㅠ 울컥하네요

I really miss him too😢😢😢

Sanha you are doing so well, you are so strong - your voice has always been so beautiful, moonbin is smiling im sure

sanha, thank you so much for this cover. happy birthday to our precious moon🥺🤍

OMg.. Sanha I wish I could give you a hug. Balling my eyes out and I have no idea how you sang this song. Bin would be proud. We all feel your pain and we are here with you.

this is soooo touching.... love the cover.... i´m sure MoonBin would love it too... thank you sanha for this song

울 막둥이 넘 고마워~~ 노래 넘 좋더라~~ 보는 내내 울컥했어 ㅠㅠ 울따나 이제 울디말구 힘내자~~ 그래야 빈이형두 좋아하지~ 그치? 아직은 힘들겠지만 우리 같이 이겨내보자~~ 울 막둥이 사랑해💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💕💕💕💕💕💕

@yeniferayala2164

4 ай бұрын

Estoy segura de que le gustó y está muy orgulloso de tener su amor!!! Feliz cumpleaños Bin!!! Cómo te sientes ahora? Estás feliz, tus hermanos y aroha te amamos, lo estás viendo? Estás feliz verdad? Es un camino duro pero tus hermanos lo están logrando, están llegando muy alto!!! Se feliz siempre Bin!!! Gracias Sanha por tan hermosa canción!!! Te quiero ❤️🫶🫰

@user-rm9qp9mj8n

4 ай бұрын

진심을 꾹꾹 눌러 담아 부른 노래라 너무 아프네,,,빈이 형아가 흐뭇하게 바라보겠다. 산하 많이 컸다구,,,빈이 생일 진심으로 축하해!!

@trixiamarielegaspi

4 ай бұрын

​

@cristinanavarro1260

4 ай бұрын

Hermosa canción. Una caricia al alma de Binnie. Gracias hermano❤

@Park-Jeon.7

4 ай бұрын

@@yeniferayala2164y luego que eun woo también le hizo una 😢😭😭😭😭me parte el alma

I LOVE YOU BABY SANHA! Aroha have your back! Everything will be better ❤

SANHA ✡️💜💜💜

Today 1year and 2months we still missssssss 😭

Happy birthday to heaven , Little moon 🌙 I appreciate and miss you ✨

Dear Sanha, I loved your cover. I'm sure Binnie loved it too. Never forget that you're not alone. You're so strong and you can be so proud of yourself. Aroha will always be here for you. Binnie is definitely looking over you right now. He's listening to you, just like we are. You are loved Sanha. We all care about you so take good care of yourself. Don't be afraid to express your feelings and lean on those who care about you. You're the best and I'll always be cheering for you.💜💜💜

We all arohas and astro members will always love and remember our beloved binnie..love the way you sing baby sanha

SANHA 💜

Sanha, I miss ASTRO so much. Thank you for posting this beautiful song. From Nevada, USA

Sanha, you’re such a strong brother. Bin will always proud of you💜

@roxannemiller6961

4 ай бұрын

He will definitely.

Sing like an angel❤

My young boy, how much have you grown to the point where you can sing to your Hyung, you don't know how proud I am of you.

Thank you Sanha for sharing your grief. You help us heal by being one with us. MoonBin is well loved. It’s thru your songs and Astro that his presence will always be real. Continue to make beautiful music.

Thank you Uri maknae Sanha... ♡´･ᴗ･`♡

He is so good and deserve more recognition.

Just tears are rolling down seeing this cover. 😭😭😭 You sang so beautifully. You sang it with your whole heart & soul our Sanha. We can see that u miss ur hyung so much. Our boy was literally holding his tears & at last when he was seeing that empty chair broke my heart. 😭😭 Missing you our Binnie. Love u guys so much our BinSan!! ♥️💜

You did really well our maknae💜 I am sure our Binnie is so proud of you👏🏻 Happiest birthday Bin😚

Thank you for this cover! One of the most heavenly voices over there. I hope everyone can heal. Binnah HAPPY BIRTHDAY!!

Bebesito tan lindo ❤❤

Hermoso❤

My beautiful Sanha, you do amazing 🥰 I'm so proud of you and thank you 💕 Binnie is so proud too 💜 We love you Sanha❤ HBD Binnie 💜

포옹과 사랑을 보냅니다. 커버가 아름답습니다. 문빈이가 커버를 듣고 기뻐하는 것을 알고 있습니다. ❤️‍🩹 그리고 자랑스러워합니다. ❤️‍🩹

Thank you so much Sanha for this beautiful expression of love and feeling. We miss you Moon Bin!

So handsome and I love your voice

빈이에게는 최고의 선물이 되었을 막내의 노래.. 착한 빈이는 자신을 그리워하는 막내의 마음을 알고 연습실에서 노래를 부르는 동생의 곁에 잠시 머무르며 노래를 듣다 갔나 보네요... 자신에게 주는 생일선물이 가득히 쌓여있다는 걸 빈이는 알까요? 막둥이가 스물 여섯이 되면 빈이가 한번 더 찾아와서 이 노래를 함께 불러줄지도 모르겠네요.. 빈이가 막내에게 줄 생일선물도 기대하며 생일 축하해 빈아 ❤

@user-es7jp1nv5i

4 ай бұрын

말이 너무 따뜻해요ㅠㅠ 그랬을거라고 생각해요ㅠㅠ

the most beautiful cover I have ever heard, thank you Sanha, we are very proud of you 💜

I want to know why a cover with such a wonderful voice has not yet received half a million views??!!! 😢

@molbertmolbert4966

4 ай бұрын

Лучшее посвящение Мунбину. Спел от души❤❤❤❤❤

Her voice is amazing, cheers up!!

All the memories just flashed back. I miss you astro. I miss you so much as 6. And I miss you so much Bin. Thank you for singing this Sanha❤ You sang it beautifully. It’s the best gift for Bin.

My dear Sanha thank you so much for sharing this beautiful cover with us, I really loved it! And I’m sure your Bin hyung too 🫶🏻 I love you so much my boy 💜🫂

Watching our baby ASTRO grow up like 🥹🥹~~ We’re so proud of you, Sanha!💜💜💜💜

Que hermosa voz, lloré toda la canción aún duele mucho. Los amo mis niños ASTRO

@Nikk3003

3 ай бұрын

😭💘Don't cry♥️

I want to give you the tightest and warmest hugs. Moonbin knows how much you all love him. Thank you for sharing this. I'm sure your heart has reached him wherever he is now. Please always keep him in your heart. Hope he becomes the strength you all need.

선곡 최고이고. 연습 정말많이 했구나. 너무 아름답다. 빈이도 우리도 너무 행복해. 고마워요🧡👏

Dear Sanha! I listen to all your covers every day. Your voice heals the soul.

빈이 너무 보고싶다 웃고 있는 빈이얼굴보고싶고 목소리 듣고 싶고 … 미쳐버릴 것 같아서 빈이영상보면서 나 울어 그냥 안녕 하면서 나와 제발…보고싶다

Dear Sanha, I can't find the words to express everything this cover generated in me. I can't imagine what it must have been like for you to sing it. I love how you changed the numbers for your ages, I got it right away. From the first moment it feels like a song that is so intimate and so deep, the emotions are felt very intensely. I cried throughout the video, but only because I find it extremely beautiful and it sounds very emotional (I am a very emotional person). None of us can judge your work, because it is Bin's gift, but as a personal opinion, I think it is the best gift you could have given. I admire how at no time did your voice falter, in fact, it sounded more powerful than ever. I have never felt your voice like that, and it is truly shocking. You show a lot of strength Sanha, not only in your voice, but in your spirit. It was very brave of you to put this together and perform this, I'm very proud of you, and I know Bin is too. I hope that making this cover has helped you heal a little more. It certainly helped me heal a little more, and I thank you for the effort you've put into this project. I wish you good luck in the future and much happiness in the present. Aroha will always be with you. Don't forget to take care of yourself, rest and eat well. But the mental and emotional part is also important, so seek support if you need it. Thank you again for everything, keep going, we support you every step of the way. Greetings from an Aroha from Argentina ❤ 산하님께, 이 커버가 저에게 해준 모든 것을 말로는 설명할 수 없습니다. 그 노래를 부를 때 어떤 느낌이었는지 상상할 수 없습니다. 나는 나이에 따라 숫자가 변하는 방식을 좋아했고 즉시 그것을 알아차렸습니다. 첫 순간부터 매우 강렬한 감정이 담긴 매우 친밀하고 깊은 노래처럼 느껴집니다. 영상이 너무 아름답고 감동적이어서 보는 내내 울었습니다(저는 감정이 풍부한 사람입니다). 비나님이 주신 선물이라 누구도 평가할 수 없지만 개인적으로는 최고의 선물이라고 생각합니다. 나는 당신의 목소리가 결코 흔들리지 않는다는 것에 놀랐습니다. 실제로 그 어느 때보다 더 강력하게 들렸습니다. 이런 목소리를 들어본 적이 없어서 정말 충격적이에요. 산하의 강인함은 목소리뿐만 아니라 정신력에서도 드러난다. 당신은 이것을 달성하기 위해 매우 용감했고 저는 당신이 매우 자랑스럽고 빈아 도 그러하다는 것을 알고 있습니다. 이 커버를 만드신 것이 여러분의 마음을 조금 더 치유하는데 도움이 되었기를 바랍니다. 그것은 확실히 제가 조금 더 치유하는 데 도움이 되었으며 이 프로젝트에 쏟은 노력에 감사드립니다. 앞으로도 행운이 가득하고 지금에도 많은 행복이 있기를 바랍니다. 아로하가 항상 여러분과 함께하겠습니다. 자신을 돌보고 휴식을 취하고 잘 먹는 것을 잊지 마십시오. 하지만 정신적, 정서적 측면도 중요하므로 필요한 경우 지원을 받으십시오. 모든 것에 다시 한번 감사드립니다. 계속 해주십시오. 우리는 모든 단계에서 귀하를 지원합니다. 안녕하세요, 아르헨티나 출신의 아로하입니다 ❤

Moonbin you will always be someone special in my life, how warm it felt to see him. His smile, his voice, his singing, his look made me feel safe and loved and it will always be like that with every memory. 🌕

빈이와의 물리적인 거리는 너무 멀지만... 또 결코 그렇게 멀리 있지만은 않을거라 생각해. 함께했던 모든것들, 떠올릴 수 있는 무엇인가가 있다면 빈이는 늘 우리곁에 산하곁에 함께할꺼야 그럴꺼라 믿어😄

Te adoro mi niñito chiquito ❤

The most heartbreaking. I wish I could just hug you yoon Sanha.

힘든 시간을 버텨주고 있는 산하도 너무 고맙고 우리 모두 행복했으면 좋겠어 산하야 항상 좋은 노래 들려줘서 너무 고마워

Beautiful song 😢😢😢😢😢😢

This will always make me cry, thank you Sanha for being so strong and sharing this with us!😭💜

산하가 이렇게 우리 빈이 기억해주고 축하해줘서, 우리까지 위로를 받는거 같아. 고맙고 고마워💜 빈이가 씨익~~ 웃는게 보이는 듯 해🌕💖

산하야 빈이가 분명히 마음에 들어했을거야! 빈이는 너무 좋겠다 동생이 이런 멋진 생일 선물도 주구🎁 우리 막둥이 언제 이렇게 컸나😊 산하야 너무 고맙고 정말 많이 사랑해💜

@roxannemiller6961

4 ай бұрын

We loved him too, I know so hard to except, I can’t even imagine how it is for you Sanha or any of you that were so close to him, I live on the other half of the world, but I/we feel the loss too, a very special loving, amazingly talented very sweet and humble human being, never to be another, his precious memories we shall hold on too forever, you always have my prayers and best wishes and support in your endeavors in life, Binnie so unforgettable, he lives on in our hearts, He is the most Beautiful and Brightest Star in the Sky, as He was an Earthly Angel that no one could deny.🥲😇❤️😘🥰💕

Until now I had the courage to see it but it was hard and always will be. Thank you Sanha 🫂 I love you so much! All of you! 💜

Muchas gracias por regalar está canción a Moonbin y compartirla con nosotros, ese sentimiento que tienes logra atravesar la pantalla, eres maravilloso Sanha 💜💜

Love you! Great cover!! Great meaning. Bin we miss you 😢 but we will never forget you!

Sanha-yaa!! Since I was busy all day, I had the opportunity to listen to the cover at around three o'clock in the night. It is very precious and beautiful to be able to hear your beautiful voice all the time. My heart breaks into pieces when I see you cry, but at the same time, I see what a strong brother, what a strong friend you are. Our pain is shared, but it is very difficult to even imagine how deep this pain is for you. But I am proud of you, Sanha, I am sure your only brother Bin is proud of you every day. That's why you are someone with a big, beautiful heart who does everything you can for us and the members. I can't explain how much I love you and how proud I am of you, my words are not enough. You are truly a wonderful person, and I wish that Sanha, who has this beautiful heart, should never experience pain, sorrow, tears and grief at any life, at any time, at any age. You are my only idol, my family, my precious. Stay strong, I will be with you every moment, I will pray every moment so that you can stay strong. I hug you big Sanha, I love you big.. 🫂🫶🏻💜✨️

Sanha voice is very charming

Amo esta cancion muchas gracias mi sanhita 💜✨😭😭😭

サナ、素敵な歌をありがとう❤ 隣の椅子に、ムンビンはきっと居ましたよ🐶😿 ムンビンの事は皆絶対忘れないし、今でも会いたくて仕方ないです😢皆同じ気持ちです🌙悲しい時は、泣いてもいいよね…

So beautiful, you have amazing strength to sing and commemorate Binnie in this video, in your rehearsal space, I am in tears. I'm sure he is looking down on you with love. 산하님의 사랑과 헌신에 감사드립니다. ❤

I Love this boy is adorable, his Voice is so nice, he transmits his feelings to us.

Beautiful my child, you were and are very strong 🥰😘